8by8
Anyone have any opinions and feedback about him ?  Any links you can provide with reviews or info ?  I'm trying to decide between him and Dr. Harold Reed (Florida), and am wanting any and all feedback.  I'm looking for ligament cuts and skin moving only, no girth work.  Perhaps turkey neck surgery later on.

Thanks everyone for such a great forum.
Quote 0 0
Miracle8x7
Both are good doctors.  Alter is likely more expensive but would be my personal preference.  Dr. Reed is a healthy alternative providing Dr. Alter is booked up, too far away, too expensive, etc.

I should mention that at your size, I wouldn't consider ANY form of phalloplasty.  Ligamentolysis will only net you a little erect length (it's mostly for show/flaccid gains).  You certainly possess plenty of girth as well.  All procedures pose risks.  You are already endowed with a penis larger than most porn stars.  Wish you well regardless of what choice you make.  Just my $.02.
Never gonna retire from PE! What? You gotta problem with dat?

Progress Report
http://phalloboards.websitetoolbox.com/post/Miracle8x7s-PMMA-Progress-Report-5391236
Quote 0 0
Bigben
I would pick Alter if you have the $$. He is very experienced, honest, and does not have a big ego like some doctors. Alter pretty much just revision work for guys and as M7 said, he is always booked out, even for a consultation.

I think Reed is more eccentric and keep in mind he older. However I am sure he could have retired a long time ago and works because he wants to, not because he needs the money.

So l would at least talk to both on the phone and see who you like better.

Try to find a few ex-patients from the forums and talk to them too. I don't remember anything bad posted about either doctor to date.
Quote 0 0
8by8
Miracle7x6 wrote:
Both are good doctors.  Alter is likely more expensive but would be my personal preference.  Dr. Reed is a healthy alternative providing Dr. Alter is booked up, too far away, too expensive, etc.

I should mention that at your size, I wouldn't consider ANY form of phalloplasty.  Ligamentolysis will only net you a little erect length (it's mostly for show/flaccid gains).  You certainly possess plenty of girth as well.  All procedures pose risks.  You are already endowed with a penis larger than most porn stars.  Wish you well regardless of what choice you make.  Just my $.02.
I'm not 8x8 yet.  I'm non bone pressed 7.5x6.5, with a BPFSL of 8.25.  I realize most white pornstars are around 7x6, most black pornstars around 8x5.75, with some above 9x6.5, and I have been affected by the "dick greed" complex most millenial porn viewers are afflicted by.  I've even at times wondered what I'd look like thru those fisheye lenses, with a tiny spinner holding mine, but hopefully, all works out with my current girlfriend, and I never need to devolve and find out where I really would stand if i were to step into that world.

But affectation aside, I have long needed to have the scar-fusing on my top shaft detached, due to my current girlfriend of 18months having had partners larger than me, and me wanting to please her well past her needs.  She is a wonderful girl, and this fusing of scar skin to my top of my shaft tugs my dick up and back when penetrating certain positions, rendering me to only being able to use around 6.75" of my length, which doesn't hit her cul-de-sac they way she likes from every position.  If this fused-tissue-both is detached and my corpus cavernosa fully freed, i should be able to hit her posterior fornix well from every position, and should gain a huge flaccid hang, which is a big visual turn on for her as well.  I f I gain some erect length from the lig cuts and aggressive post-op traction (which I will go to town with), that will be incredible and a dream come true.

We really love each other on every quantifiable and abstract level, and we are both pleasers.  This is just me needing to please, and needing to make right a botched Rodney Barron procedure where I had an open scar over two weeks past my surgery date, of which I had to pull out all the expensive alloderm which didn't take and went to waste.  Although I'm glad, as Dr. Barron didn't tell me it was actually pigskin, and I try to stay Kosher 100%.

I will definitely consider talking to both doctors, but I would tend to favor Dr. Gary Alter, despite very much liking the eccentric enthusiasm and obvious intellectual fervor of Dr. Reed.
Quote 0 0
8by8
Does anyone have any more info regarding Dr. Alter ?  I emailed him and got a very pleasant and assuring response from him, but that was over a year ago.

I had a financial issue that slowed me down for awhile, but I've saved up enough where the cost is worth it now for me again.   If anyone can give me that push I need to go thru with it, I would greatly appreciate it.

BTW, still with the same girl now, over 2.5 years [smile]

Any and all posters with words regarding their experiences with the man whom appears to be the most respected PE / lig cut surgeon on earth today, would be most definitely appreciated.

Thank you.
Quote 0 0
New1inch
8by8 wrote:
Miracle7x6 wrote:
Both are good doctors.  Alter is likely more expensive but would be my personal preference.  Dr. Reed is a healthy alternative providing Dr. Alter is booked up, too far away, too expensive, etc.

I should mention that at your size, I wouldn't consider ANY form of phalloplasty.  Ligamentolysis will only net you a little erect length (it's mostly for show/flaccid gains).  You certainly possess plenty of girth as well.  All procedures pose risks.  You are already endowed with a penis larger than most porn stars.  Wish you well regardless of what choice you make.  Just my $.02.
I'm not 8x8 yet.  I'm non bone pressed 7.5x6.5, with a BPFSL of 8.25.  I realize most white pornstars are around 7x6, most black pornstars around 8x5.75, with some above 9x6.5, and I have been affected by the "dick greed" complex most millenial porn viewers are afflicted by.  I've even at times wondered what I'd look like thru those fisheye lenses, with a tiny spinner holding mine, but hopefully, all works out with my current girlfriend, and I never need to devolve and find out where I really would stand if i were to step into that world.

But affectation aside, I have long needed to have the scar-fusing on my top shaft detached, due to my current girlfriend of 18months having had partners larger than me, and me wanting to please her well past her needs.  She is a wonderful girl, and this fusing of scar skin to my top of my shaft tugs my dick up and back when penetrating certain positions, rendering me to only being able to use around 6.75" of my length, which doesn't hit her cul-de-sac they way she likes from every position.  If this fused-tissue-both is detached and my corpus cavernosa fully freed, i should be able to hit her posterior fornix well from every position, and should gain a huge flaccid hang, which is a big visual turn on for her as well.  I f I gain some erect length from the lig cuts and aggressive post-op traction (which I will go to town with), that will be incredible and a dream come true.

We really love each other on every quantifiable and abstract level, and we are both pleasers.  This is just me needing to please, and needing to make right a botched Rodney Barron procedure where I had an open scar over two weeks past my surgery date, of which I had to pull out all the expensive alloderm which didn't take and went to waste.  Although I'm glad, as Dr. Barron didn't tell me it was actually pigskin, and I try to stay Kosher 100%.

I will definitely consider talking to both doctors, but I would tend to favor Dr. Gary Alter, despite very much liking the eccentric enthusiasm and obvious intellectual fervor of Dr. Reed.


Do you actually believe she's had bigger than you? your length and girth is way above average. I think she's bullshitting you. If I was you Id leave my dick alone and go on about my life. You have a huge dick already. No wonder she's sticking around..lol.. what you have is rare.
Manual PE WORKS!! 
Feb. 2013-BPEL 5.0" EG 4.95" FL 3.0" 
May. 2013-BPEL 5.5" EG 5.1" FL 4.0" 
Aug. 2013-BPEL 6.0" EG 5.0" FL 4.5" 
Jun.  2014-BPEL 5.625" EG 4.95 FL 4.0" 
Aug. 2016- BPEL 5.50"  EG 4.95  FL 3.75" 
Nov. 2018- BPEL 6.5”  EG n/a FL na **NEW

Goal: 7"EL x 6"EG

Follow Me On My Journey to find a inch:
http://phalloboards.websitetoolbox.com/post/my-journey-to-find-an-inch-6215675?trail=15
Quote 0 0
kapitalizam
7.5 x 6.5 and go for phaloplasty???? This crazy world surprises me every day, it's hilarious.... I love life [smile]
Quote 0 0
smalljay
^^^LOL Kapitalizam....

8by8, I'm curious if you've tried manual stretching, extending, or hanging yet (without surgery). Many (in fact, most who are dedicated and consistent) report real gains from it. New1Inch gained one inch with manual stretches alone, and no surgery (his pics and progress report are the crown jewel of the manual PE section here, but many more examples can be found over at thundersplace.org). Have you considered or tried this? Because if I were you, that would easily be my first option. You've already waited over a full year since posting this thread, so you obviously aren't in a rush. Why not at least try it, and avoid the somewhat common possible issue of retracted length after lig cutting surgery? Imagine going in there expecting more length, but ending up with even less weeks later! How devastated would you be? It happens more often than you think. Some guys are able to regain the lost length, but sadly, some guys aren't.


I'm also curious, with you being such a long guy, as to what the minimum length you feel is needed to reach the cervix, and what length you feel is needed to reach beyond the cervix and into the cul-de-sac.
I know with your girl you said that 6.75" can hit cul de sac at only some angles - but starting at 5.75" this would still be a dream for me (with 6.75" being near my ultimate end goal). So, don't be afraid to hurt my feelings, but in YOUR experience with the women YOU'VE been with, what's the minimum length needed to hit the cervix, and what's the minimum length needed to go beyond that to the Cul De Sac?

-Smalljay
Quote 0 0
smalljay
Anybody else have any stories or experience with Dr. Alter?

Here's a very long interview with him and Dr. Drew from way back in 2003. Still very informative. This guy was ahead of his time - at this point he had already stopped performing risky girth procedures:

Quote 0 0
Sugarmill2005
Checked with him about ligament cut and glans enlargement. Said he didn't do glans enlargement and more or less said ligament cut was a waste of time .
Quote 0 0