Reklaw
Has anyone used all 3 ?
Ive searched the forum and can only find single reviews, not a comparison of all 3.
My main concern is finding one that isn’t going to slip off the glans
Id appreciate the feedback from anyone who’s used them, thanks.
Quote 2 0
think
I'm interested in this also, but have only used the silistretcher. I just started using it with the 1" wide sleeves and there's no way that was slipping off. The 0.75" sleeve was too tight, can't see how most people can use them. It's supposed to come with 2 of each, but mine only came with one 1" and it ripped last night, so now I need to wait for a replacement.  
Quote 1 0
Friend face
Penimaster Pro is good quality but expensive you have to buy the correct sleeves or you won't get much suction, Replacement parts are expensive also.The other 2 i haven't tried.
Quote 1 0
Texas
@Reklaw 
I have a phallosan and a Sili.    Never went with a pro due my assumption it was more like a extender than what I like.   
I hate phallosan's.   Reason =  The ring always ends up becoming an irritant at the base of my cock.   But, Even more over than that, i found it really difficult to get on and off.   And I ended breaking the little flimsy sleeves, twice.   These things could just be me though. 
So,  with that said:   lets say that the ring does not end up bothering you, then your good to go.  Or, perhaps maybe it does bother you, so you simply will need to adjust it every hour or two as it becomes a problem.  There,  problem solved.   For the taking on and off part;  I guess practice would solve this problem.  
The biggest positive with this product,  it is fairly clandestine. You can wear with most clothes.   Except to the gym - on a day where you lay down.  DONT DO THAT. 

On to the Sili.   I really like this product.  But I also prefer to hang and stretch as my main PE.    I use this product for both.    So far, very durable .    NOTE:  I do not use any of the sleeves that come with it.  I swap ever sleeve on any product with Autoextender sleeves for comfort reasons.   
This has never slipped off me,  ever.  
Con:  Its fairly big ( comparable to the LG ).  so you wont be wearing this in public much at all.    I wear this to the gym a lot in sweats.    

OK,  on to the Pro. 
I do not have one.  But still will probably get one for these reasons:   
1.  It looks clandestine enough to hide.  Only a trail will tell. 
2. I have realized that you dont have to use the extender part.  I hate most extenders. 
3.  Always for something more comfortable than what I have and use. 

The reason I am chiming in on here, is this:  I currently use two modified products that are basically the same concept as the penimaster pro basic.  I use an autoextender head cup and an autoextender sleeve, and nothing else.  I use this with an ankle or knee strap.  it is a pretty easy set up and also mostly clandestine.  I'd be curious if the pro head cup offers more conceal-abilty  and or comfort. 
Quote 1 0
think
@Texas why do you hate extenders vs stretchers, if you're using both with a vac? I hate noose type extenders, and even the x4labs comfort thing wasn't great but if an extender has a vac head then either using tension bars attached or a cord attached to a leg or waist belt are both stretching the penis from the vac head the same way, except tension bars are straight out, whereas a belt can pull it down on an angle towards one leg. Is it just the angle you prefer?
Quote 2 0
think
I also concur with @Texas that I like the silistretcher, and it is a bit large and requires sweats, and even then isn't the most discreet. 
Quote 1 0
astroman

Wanted to share my email to Reklaw:

I've tried several different systems over the years and found the Penimaster Pro system to be best in terms of comfort and ease of use. I'd recommend getting a Chinese knock-off product which is much cheaper and uses better materials IMO:

Aliexpress: search for "BICHI penis hood transparent bulb"

You'll also need replacement sluices and diaphragms. I didn't like the Chinese versions so I get mine from the Urology Health Store. You may find an alternative source based in the UK.

https://www.urologyhealthstore.com/shop/men-products/peyronies-disease/penimaster-additional-accessories-replacement-parts/penimaster-pro-replacement-sluices/

https://www.urologyhealthstore.com/shop/men-products/peyronies-disease/penimaster-additional-accessories-replacement-parts/penimaster-pro-extra-diaphragms/

I use the largest size for both, but you may want to order a few of each medium and large sizes to see what fits best. These last about a month or so if you use everyday.

In terms of extenders, there are several good options. I have only used the SizeGenetics extender which is a bit pricier but works great. You'll need to buy an endpiece that attaches to the vacuum bulb, which you can find if you search Aliexpress for "BICHI Stretcher Extensions Head."

This may not work for you, but it's cheap to try.

I haven't tried the Forte but I have used a very similar system. You'll get a better stretch with the Forte but it's more cumbersome to use IMO. Also, if you don't tape your glans before using a system like the Forte you'll inevitably get a blister on the glans. I've gotten blisters with the Penimaster too so no system is perfect.

If you want to save money this system is very similar to the Forte at a fraction of the price:

https://www.aliexpress.com/item/32940833409.html?spm=a2g0o.productlist.0.0.484c4134N45aaX&algo_pvid=eebef51b-a410-40df-a23e-d37430a1e626&algo_expid=eebef51b-a410-40df-a23e-d37430a1e626-0&btsid=9c2f6f90-ca86-4bf3-bcc7-4368f414cf92&ws_ab_test=searchweb0_0,searchweb201602_7,searchweb201603_55

Once you figure out what size works best you'll want to order extra glans caps and sleeves because they don't last very long.

Quote 2 0
Texas
@think 
I find them to cumbersome and irritatingly in the way of anything and everything other than sitting around at the desk or watching tv.   But, This is my preference.    However, if I did like them: It would never involve a noose extender.  The x4 was garbage to me.    The pro seems to have some merit.  If I bought it, i would use it like the sili stretcher by drilling a small whole in the end tip and attach it to my leg strap and start my day logging hours.  

As for stretching comparison as you mentioned: I find them to be two very different stretches.  Yes, the penis may be getting stretched in the overall same way and direction but:   In an extender, your stretch is very defined to whatever angle you are pointing it whereas when in a sleeve, and attached to a strap, it moves around more because of how it is attached.   Yes, the angle of attaching your penis to a leg strap will only be downward compared to that of the extender,  but you will be able to wear it a shit load longer to.  Plus, most people wont be fitting an extender inside there pants.  I have no real preference in angle, to answer your other question, I just tend to be able to rack up more hours at that angle as most would.  EG:  Sitting at my desk with it out or pulled through and hanging weights, or hiding in my pants while i walk around. 

These two types of products may both hold a place in the PE arsenal For Sure.    But given the original question of comparing all three, I would find the stretcher most versatile.   
And on that note:  @Reklaw.   I would think that the sili stretcher (or other similar aforementioned contraption ) would have the least chance of "slipping" off a dick.  To answer your original question directly.   This is because, you have a whole sleeve that would have to pull off with the head unit.  
Quote 1 0
Bloke
I purchased a penimaster pro package mainly due to its diverse user options and potential comfort for extended use. I used the vac and rods and vac and shoulder leg strap for the first few months then started using the vac attachment for hanging over the past few months. It was tricky to use at first, the rubber gland and sluice pieces break/need replacing and getting the right size for your glands will aid suction and comfort.
I worked ammy usage up and am now able to wear mine for 6-8 hrs day, or 3-4 as a hanger. I have made good gains over the past 5-6 months using this with manual stretches. I have gained 20mm girth and 25mm (+/-5mm) EL. These were mostly newbie gains.....gains are getting much more difficult as it goes on. I also aven'thave the penimaster with the strap but i don't use it as it pinches and glands slip out when you apply decent force, I don't recommend strap devices fir this reason. Good luck with it.
Quote 1 0
Friend face
@astroman  I've tried several different systems over the years and found the Penimaster Pro system to be best in terms of comfort and ease of use. I'd recommend getting a Chinese knock-off product which is much cheaper and uses better materials IMO:

I bought a Chinese knock off Penimaster and it was poor quality and it broke easily.
Quote 0 0
Herbert West
@Reklaw  In addition to PM I want to add that there's no perfect stretching device on the market. All of them are not comfortable and if we talk about vacuum system all of them tends to blister formation if you wear it too long or put a bit more tension than you can tolerate without injury. Noose system even less comfortable but it can give much more tension than vacuum device.
Quote 1 0
anon1998
I need some hanger ! I have penimaster pro , i use the stretcher and also the belt ,

I need some hanger now , any advices ? Some hanger that is good and not so painful , price doesn’t matter , also easily to put ... 
Quote 0 0
Reklaw
Alright lads off topic but I thought I’d post this small clip just released by Vice
Thanks for all the feedback everyone, I’ll be updating this thread when my Silistretcher arrives tomorrow.
Quote 0 0
Herbert West

@Reklaw 

 

How it's going?

Quote 0 0
Reklaw

@Herbert West 

Im good thanks, Ive been quite busy hence why I haven’t been active, thanks for everyone who contributed to this thread.
I ended up buying the Silistretcher in the Black Friday sale, I’m really impressed with it, but it’s the only one I’ve tried so that’s not much to go on, the only other device I tried was the Jes Extender years ago, the only thing that’s good for is decapitating your glans.

Quote 0 0